Paranormal Revenge

I remember the exact moment that everything started.

The house felt different.

Right from the start, I felt the house was hiding from me.

They're not expecting to end up embroiled in a turf war with the other side.

It was like a death stare.

It was terrifying.

Well, I think this might be a clue

into who this person might be.

Just like a jigsaw puzzle,

it all clicked together and it made sense.

That's enough of this.

And I got mad.

Things start to progress

and fast.

This entity cut him up.

He's being manipulated by something

that has a far more sinister purpose.

It's gonna continue to get worse

as long as the spirit is in the house.

Dead. Done. Dead silence.

All hell broke loose.

New Hampshire in general

is a beautiful part of the country.

Before I moved to Derry, I liv,

and I lived in a smaller house.

I was there for 20 years.

During the pandemic, when we were all home,

we realized that we were all on top of each other.

The name of this house is the Alanson Tucker Mansion.

I did not know any history about this house.

I didn't know it was called the Alanson Tucker House

when I was purchasing it.

My first impression of this house was it was overwhelming.

My husband was the one that found the house.

He was very excited about it and.

So when I first saw it, I thought, wow.

I said, "This is more than I planned on getting into."

This case of Colleen and Colin Costello

is really interesting to me

because here they are moving into this very old building

and, you know, that really speaks to the fact

that there's such a layered history here,

and also that spirits really feel attached,

to specific places.

Richard Estep, take one.

The case of Colleen Costello reminds me of the old saying

that there's no place like home.

When she and her husband move into the home of their dreams,

they're not expecting to end up embroiled in a turf war

with the other side.

When this opportunity arose

to own like a historical house like this,

it was kind of exciting in one way.

But at the same time, kind of,

I don't know if I wanna do this.

I walked around the house.

As he's like amazed by everything and saying,

"My God, don't you feel how amazing?"

You know?

I was surprised because I normally pick up an energy

in any home, it doesn't have to be an old home,

but in any home when I walk into it, you know,

good, bad energy, whatever.

There was no energy in the home.

I didn't feel anything.

And it was so bizarre

because being over a 200-year-old house,

that there'd have to be some energy in there.

Nothing.

Right from the start, I felt the house was hiding from me.

We moved in and after a day of unpacking,

we went to bed.

About 4:30 in the morning,

we started to hear all this clattering and banging

downstairs in the kitchen.

We could hear it from the room.

We were like, we just moved in here.

Is there somebody downstairs?

Has somebody broken in?

So we came out here to-to look and to listen to the noise

that was coming from the kitchen downstairs.

As quickly as it started, it just stopped like that.

Boom, everything just stopped dead.

Done. Dead silence.

We did go down and there was nothing.

Nothing was out of place.

So that was the first night.

My neighbour next door has lived here for fifty years.

She introduced herself and had ma

and walked me all the way down to a pond

that was at the back of her garden,

which I didn't even know was there

because you can't actually see it from my house.

When she showed me the pond,

I immediately just had this really awful feeling

that there was something awful happened there.

I couldn't explain it,

but it was just a really bad feeling

around the pond area.

Things take a special turn

when Colleen begins to hear voices in her head

and specifically a woman's voice.

I was in my living room and I was just sitting,

I was just sitting in my living room.

I have something I need to tell you.

And I heard this voice and she said to me,

"I need to talk to you.

"I have something I need to tell you."

I was a patient here.

She was a patient here in this house

and her name was Betsy.

And that she said too much, that she talked too much.

And that they disposed of her.

In the pond.

In the pond.

I found out the house was a care home again

from my neighbour next door.

She filled me in on a lot of history of the house

that I wasn't even aware of.

I was told that it was licenced for, I think, 12 patients

and it had 42 patients.

They shouldn't have had that many people in this house

because there wasn't enough ro.

When she told me that, I was like, my God,

that's why I felt that way when I was at the pond.

It was like a jigsaw puzzle,

it all clicked together and it made sense.

We make the discovery that Colleen's home

was once a nursing home

and conditions in that home were not necessarily the best.

The nursing home was filled over capacity.

It was packed, it was crowded.

There weren't enough staff

to take care of the needs of everybody who lived there.

Conditions there were miserable.

We had just gotten into bed

and I, my side of the bed was towards the door

that goes into the nanny's room.

I never liked that side of the room.

I felt like somebody was gonna come through that door.

We're sleepi.

In the middle of the night,

um, I felt like I was being pushed from behind.

I'm being pushed towards the edge of the bed,

so I'm literally being shoved.

All of a sudden I realize I'm gonna fall out of the bed.

So then I took my hand and I went, "What the heck?"

I said, "What the hell are you doing?" And I put my hand back and I went, "Stop!

"Will you stop shoving me?"

And I put my hand back to say, stop

and as I did that, that's when I realized

there was no one there.

There was a gap of that much between him and me

and he was way over here.

And that's when I realized

that he wasn't the one shoving me out of the bed.

I went, "My God."

I woke my husband up and he goes, "What's wrong?"

And I was like,

"I thought you were shoving me out of the bed."

And he goes, "No"-

He goes, "I haven't been, I haven't gone near you."

So I was absolutely terrified.

That was very, very scary for me.

Colleen is kicked out of her own bed,

which makes me infer on the history,

the fact that this was residential home

that was at over capacity,

um, which, you know, you could have spirits, um,

that didn't have beds, they didn't have space.

It's entirely possible

that the shoving Colleen experienced in the bed

was a spirit from the nursing home.

We know that this was overcrowded.

We can reasonably believe

that people were crammed into beds,

multiple people into one bed.

Pushing and shoving would be something I would expect

under those circumstances.

But then a clue comes to light that reveals

this might all have been triggered

before they even moved in.

Right before we moved in, my husband had a dream.

The dream he had was of the basement of this house.

In the corne, there was this dark shadow.

It was a girl and she was crying.

What's wrong? What's wrong?

Are you okay?

No.

What's wrong?

I need to go upstairs.

And she said, "I need to go upstairs."

I want to go upstairs.

I said, "I hope you said no."

And he said, "Yeah, yeah, of course I did.

"Of course I said no."

I wanna go upstairs.

Only to find out later on,

after we moved in and things started escalating in the house,

that he actually said yes.