Doubt

Previously on Doubt...

Molly's here. She's a witness for the prosecution.

You adopted Molly when she was four?

Yes, a year younger than Billy.

Was she even here when Amy was killed?

She went back to Korea the same year, didn't she?

Her biological mother showed up, demanding to see Molly.

What are you going to tell them?

I'm gonna say what I saw!

These are her psychiatric records.

Tapes of her sessions.

Save my boy, Sadie.

My mom looks at me and sees...

Not Billy.

Like I'm the opposite.

He's funny and smart and I'm...

I don't know, not.

And you think she wants you to be like Billy?

Um, yeah.

And how does that make you feel about him?

Billy?

I love Billy.

It's not his fault that he's the chosen one.

So I've been listening to the tapes

that Margaret brought us of Molly and her therapist.

It's mostly about Margaret. Love-hate.

We probably can't use them in court.

No, but we can use what we find on them.

Well, have you found anything?

The mere fact that she went to a shrink helps the case.

Establishes her as an unreliable witness.

True. But Billy's very protective of Molly,

and he doesn't want us to do a total takedown.

Would he rather spend the rest of his life in prison?

Anyway, what happened between that tape

and the night of the murder to make her turn on Billy?

We have two years of therapy sessions,

so I'm gonna need people to help listen and see what's there.

I start a trial today.

I'm going to Bedford and meeting your mom.

Oh, don't let her push you around.

Why would she push me around?

For fun?

Would you stop that?

I'm sorry. I was just waiting for my bar results,

and I thought if I hit refresh every two seconds,

it'd make them come faster.

You're gonna pass. And if you don't,

you'll take it again.

I'm sure that was meant to reassure me, but what I heard

was “You'll never amount to anything, you idiot.”

You can listen to the tapes today.

Maybe it'll take your mind off the bar.

And where is Tiffany?

Uh, she went to Iowa for the weekend.

She's supposed to be back this morning.

Which I remember because it's the same day

I get my bar results, confirming my life is meaningless.

I'm back,

and I'm engaged.

To-to Brandon, my boyfriend from high school.

It was very sudden, but it felt right!

Mazel tov. ALL: Congratulations!

Oh, oh, that reminds me.

Dylan wants to talk to us about her divorce.

Harrison and I agreed

to, uh, work out a divorce settlement

without lawyers, okay?

And we had a meeting scheduled for today.

And then he calls me this morning and tells me

he's bringing an attorney.

Did he say what changed his mind?

- No! - I told you not to marry him.

Are you seriously gloating over my failed marriage, here?

Maybe we should just...

Maybe if you spent a little time with him,

to try to get to know him... I'm busy running a law firm.

Trust me, I know. Too busy for dinner. Yeah.

I ask you to dinner all the time.

Really, Dad? I-In the city. I live in Westchester. Really?

Maybe we should just focus on today's meeting, yeah?

- Fine. - You obviously need someone

to sit in with you to make sure the settlement is fair.

Don't worry. I'll be there.

Uh, Harrison is a little terrified of you.

What did I ever do to him?

At our wedding, you told him if he'd hurt me,

you would have him killed, Dad.

Yeah, I remember that joke. Yeah.

It wasn't really the highlight of your toast, Isaiah.

Well, I-I wasn't joking.

Okay. Here is what we are going to do.

Dylan, call Harrison, tell him

to meet us here with his lawyer.

I will sit in and make sure the settlement is fair.

Isaiah, you will stay away from the conference room.

What, it's not me Harrison has to hide from.

Oh, my gosh. Sadie.

He's gonna put a hit out on Harrison.

He's joking, and he is not funny.

So he is going to stop. Okay?

We all good here?

- So you had an exciting weekend. - I did.

I didn't realize things were so serious with...

Brandon. I mean, we've been together forever.

Since high school.

With breaks. Don't worry.

I sowed my wild oats.

I see the judgment in your eyes.

Oh, that's not judgment.

That's fear, panic,

an obsessive need to check my email again.

Well, go ahead.

Nope. Hmm.

So, how'd he ask you?

So, he's a little league coach.

And they had a game.

After the game was over, he walked up to the mound

holding a microphone and asked me to join him,

and in front of everybody, he got down on one knee

and he proposed.

So when's he moving to New York?

Oh, I don't know. It was such a whirlwind,

we didn't really get into specifics.

But he is moving to New York?

Yeah.

Wait. You don't think he thinks

that I'm moving to Iowa, do you?

I-I-I can't move back to Iowa.

I-I have a career here.

- What does he do? - He has a landscaping bus...

Uh, maybe he could do rooftop gardens.

I'm gonna text him. Um,

“Hey you!”

“You're moving to New York, right?”

Smiley face. It's settled.

Right?

I heard it first.

The screeching. Cab came out of nowhere.

It jumped the curb and hit the man.

Did it seem like the driver was trying to hit him?

Oh, yes.

Well, the man was running away,

and the cab turned very sharply

onto the sidewalk. Now, I don't know

if he was trying to cut him off

or to hit him, but... he was aiming.

And do you see the driver in the courtroom today?

Yes. He's right there.

Hello, Mr. Kalabi.

Let the record reflect that Mrs. Webster has identified

the defendant, Tariq Kalabi.

Your witness.

When you first heard the screech, where were you?

- On the ground. - Why?

The man had pushed me down and had taken my purse.

Just to be clear, the man who Mr. Kalabi accidentally hit,

had just stolen your purse?

- Yes. - Outside a bank, just minutes

after you cashed your social security check?

- Yes. - What happened after Mr. Kalabi's cab

hit the man who robbed you?

He stood over that robber until the police came.

Then he brought me my purse,

and asked if I was okay.

Such a nice young man.

Then what happened?

Then the police officer put handcuffs on Mr. Kalabi.

Said he was under arrest.

It all seemed very unfair to me.

We made a list

of Harrison and Dylan's possessions.

I thought we'd just go through them one at a time.

Well, actually, I've already drafted a settlement proposal.

Oh. What?

Get all the undisputed items out of the way first.

This basically covers all the possessions

that are easily distinguishable

between his or hers.

His golf clubs.

Her shoe collection.

Easy, breezy.

Okay.

Just take that, and look at it.

I-I'm not agreeing to this list.

Do you want my golf clubs?

I don't see the Mickey Mantle card.

Well, that would fall

under Harrison's baseball card collection.

Which I've had since I was ten.

Okay, h-he bought the Mickey Mantle card eight years ago

from a friend, and we were married at the time,

so wouldn't half of that belong to me?

I believe it would.

Am I supposed to cut it in half?

I-If that's the best way to split it up, then, yeah.

Do you see me going after your autographed Celine Dion T-shirt?

Oh, you can have it. Maybe it'll look good on Janet.

- Who's Janet? - Uh, this large animal vet who moved in

down the street. The animals are large.