Are You My First?

Previously, the girls voted Hakeem and Krash

to be sacrificed from the island.

But before they go, the guys must break their tied vote

and seal one girl's fate.

Katya and Carissa...

...both have a strong connection, but one must go.

You need to come to a decision right now.

Is anyone gonna change their vote?

-I'm not changing my vote. -I'm not changing mine.

It's a lot. It's a lot.

I'm here to find love.

I'm here to find my husband.

And I have this great connection with Andrew.

So, if I go home, that would be heartbreaking.

I'm hoping to stay

because me and Mike have a genuine connection.

And I genuinely wanna look for a relationship.

Alright, guys.

Did someone from the group want to reveal

what your guys' final decision is?

Let's let Hakeem. Hakeem.

It's his last night. Let Hakeem reveal that.

Sure, why not?

So, Hakeem,

which woman did the men vote to leave Are You My First?

We voted for Carissa.

That means, Carissa,

you have been sacrificed.

I'm sorry.

This sucks. I didn't think it was gonna be me, honestly.

I mean, who could possibly have voted for me?

That means that Krash, Hakeem, and Carissa,

it is time to say goodbye here to everybody on the island.

This is crazy.

No. I don't want you to leave.

You did amazing.

Come here, Hakeem.

I came here to look for a compatible girlfriend.

Yeah, a little bit bummed it didn't shake out like that.

- -Much love. We outta here.

Mr. 305, out.

- -

It definitely would've been cool to lose my virginity,

but Krash is definitely gonna find love in the future,

even if I didn't find it here.

- -

- - Don't cry. I love you guys.

Obviously, it's really sad to have to leave everyone,

but I'm really grateful for the opportunity

and the experience.

I definitely have so much more confidence now as a virgin

in the power and the beauty of what it means to be vulnerable.

And I'm ready to lose my virginity.

It just makes zero sense to me.

Like, her name never should have been brought up

if we're going just based off of where connections are at.

I mean, I think it's pretty clear.

You know, some of the guys didn't get the attention that they wanted from her.

And I think it ultimately just boils down to

just lack of maturity.

- -What the fuck?

It was really good to meet you.

-You okay? -Yeah.

If I'm gonna be completely honest,

I think the guys chose me

because Noah's a little hurt that I rejected him

and he's out for some revenge.

I was just being honest with everyone.

That came back to bite me.

Wow.

This gets very real very quick, huh?

-Yeah. -You said it.

Shocking.

You can head on back and we will see you later.

Okay. Goodnight.

-Goodnight. -Goodnight.

Yeah, we don't know where he's at, but...

Yeah. It's a lot to process.

Michael's gone for whatever reason.

Carissa gets sent home,

who was like-- I thought everybody loved her.

It just goes to show that it's really important

to work on building a connection here.

The remaining virgins have survived their first sacrifice.

And while some connections ended,

others got a second chance.

After her escape earlier,

Andrew's stoked he can see Katya later

and didn't have to say, "Catch ya later."

-First of all, can I just say thank you? -Yeah, of course.

It's a huge gesture.

Obviously, I want you to stay,

-and I want to continue our connection. -Of course.

I'm all in for you. I don't even want to talk to the other girls.

Mm, I'm, like, scared 'cause we're gonna--

I feel like we're gonna lock in.

-Why are you scared of that? -'Cause it's sc-- I'm a runner.

- Let's run together. -I...

It's so-- This is-- I don't do this!

-This is hard. -Just, run. Just--

You have to meet me where I'm at.

I'll meet you where you at, but just run with me, not away from me.

Like, I'm not putting pressure here.

I just wanna make sure, like, you're actually invested in this.

Well, you're obviously my number one.

And you make me feel so secure

and so safe and so comfortable.

And you deserve that and more.

And I'm gonna try my best.

-Okay. -So, that's a start, right?

Yeah, it's a start.

Katya, the thing about her,

she's more of a slow burner.

The feelings that I've grown for Katya are incredible.

I have goosebumps right now

to know that a person I met days ago

has the potential to want to build a life with me.

I definitely can see myself losing my virginity to her.

Fighting tooth and nail for me to stay

was definitely worthy of a smooch.

Our connection really is super special.

Are you more like, a hand-holding or arm around you or--

-I like being close to you right now. -You're like-- You like being close? Okay.

I've been set in my ways for so long.

I'm 28 years old, you know?

I-I have built this wall around myself for protection.

But maybe that's why I'm a virgin.

So, I'm nervous, but I'm ready to open up

in a way that I haven't allowed myself to with Andrew.

And he's the perfect person for me to be vulnerable with,

'cause he's laid it all out on the table.

After last night's wakeup call,

the virgins are eager

-to start forming connections. -

Some keep building on their bonds.

-Hello! I haven't seen you. - I know!

Others, like Noah and Ty, have both found a deep connection.

Hey, gorgeous.

Hopefully they'll try forming one with some girls, too.

Just know, I wanna be best friends forever.

Dude, same. I will always be in your corner.

-I know you-- I know-- -Wait.

Wait, wait, wait. Wait, wait, wait, wait.

Shut the fuck up.

- Is there a girl? -No, look.

Do you see that?

Or am I tripping?

-Is someone coming? -Oh yeah, same thing.

Shut the fuck up.

- -No!

Holy shit!

Dang, we just had an elimination

and now the new girls show up.

Like, it's rough out here, okay?

I think there's two.

- -I will be nice.

Unless they go for Noah, and then I will be a little bit angry.

Oh fuck.

Crazy, bro. Two?

Like, I'm freaking the fuck out!

I don't want him to fuckin' look at another girl,

and wanna date her.

Cuties!

-There's a V card! -Ooh!

- -

Last night, the island gods claimed their first sacrifices,

but today, bless us with a bountiful harvest

of two new ladies set to plant the seeds of trouble.

Will our couples keep growing,

or be uprooted?

And will I ever stop this agriculture metaphor?

- She has a V card. - Oh, for sure!

They're absolutely drop-dead gorgeous.

Especially the blonde hair, blue-eyed girl.

She's my type through and through.

Let's just be the confident queens that we are.