Haven

Previously on Haven...

Found your adoption file where you hid it

with Cabot's journal.

I hid it so you wouldn't know that I was from the other side,

so you wouldn't force me to that cave against my will.

What happened in the cave?

Something terrible came through that door.

I'm so sorry, Audrey.

Don't talk to Mara. Talk to me.

It's the only way that I can fight her.

You need to stop talking to Mara.

You need to treat her like Audrey.

- We're here for you, Audrey. - I know you can hear me.

- We need you. - She's been lying.

She can only put them in.

So Audrey was rattling around inside of me.

I'm going to kill that bitch right now.

Nope.

Still don't like pancakes.

You know what your big problem with your

"treat me like Audrey so Audrey returns" strategy is?

Well, besides the fact that I killed her,

is it requires I get utensils.

You want to have another dance?

Not at the moment, Parker.

Good idea.

You know what I will take, though?

One of those tacos.

They taste like the bottom of that dock,

but I actually prefer that kind of a flavor.

- I have an idea. - Hmm.

We could force-feed you your pancakes.

Get close to my mouth, and I'll bite you too.

Yeah, that's fine,

'cause we can just feed you through another...

Duke.

Let's talk outside.

Sure.

What?

We can't let her get to us.

Treating Mara like Audrey is the only thing

that's brought Audrey back.

Yeah, that was before Mara knew

that Audrey was still in there,

but now Mara knows.

Look, Nathan...

What if Audrey really is gone?

What if she's not?

Okay, fine.

But I'm telling you, I have gone as far as I can

treating that...

B-i-t-c-h like Audrey.

We can go further.

Come on.

Oh, great.

You're listening to WQDN, 94.7 FM...

North Carolina's best country music station.

North Carolina weather this morning

will be unseasonably cool.

Surf in the outer banks running two to three feet.

And in other news,

the Tar Heels continue their winning streak.

Stay tuned.

Why "croatoan"?

Find what you're looking for?

Uh, oh, not yet.

How long has the historical society doubled as a diner?

Since as long as I can remember.

And why is it called the Old Croatoan Cafe?

Do you know the legend?

Well, I've, uh, done some research.

Uh... oh.

In 1587, some colonists were left at their settlement

here on Roanoke Island

while their leader went to England for provisions.

But when he returned, the settlement was abandoned...

No clues, no bodies,

every single settler gone,

wiped from the earth, except...

One clue... the word "croatoan" carved in a tree.

- Yes. - People love the story.

I'm the owner, Allison Doohan.

Oh.

Good morning. Vince Teagues.

First time in Manteo?

That it is. I'm a reporter from Haven, Maine.

I'm working on a little human-interest story

about two brothers.

One of them hails from here, and the other from Haven.

What's the local family's name?

No idea. That's why I'm here.

Hoping to find some answers.

I'm sorry, but I don't recall ever hearing any stories

about two brothers.

Well, if you'll excuse me,

I better look after some of my other customers.

Let me know if you need anything.

Oh, you know,

I think I might have a cup of coffee

before I get started.

One sec.

Oh.

Thanks, Vincent.

Be late, make me pay for the coffee.

And you don't even get us a table.

Buy your own damn coffee when you get here.

Excuse me. Hey, Bob...

Free coffee. 'Scuse me.

Oh!

For the love of Pete.

What...

What the...

Wha...

No. No.

No!

Vince?

What the hell am I doing in Vince's body?

"Dave"?

Dave?

What have you done?

You... you okay?

Do you still want that cup of coffee?

"Croatoan."

Why does it say that?

The lost Roanoke colony.

- Remember? - Roanoke colony?

Where the hell am I?

Manteo, North Carolina.

Oh, excuse me.

Oh. Oh.

What did you do, Dave?

If I wasn't in here, I'd wring your neck!

Doing your morning affirmation in the mirror there,

are we, Dave?

Oh, yeah. I-I mean, no.

Yeah. So how is the information coming along

- from Cincinnati? - Cincinnati?

Yeah, I'm still waiting for it.

Dave.

If you're using that wacky tobacky medically,

go easy on that stuff.

Have you noticed anything or anyone acting strange?

Besides you? No.

But it's Haven, and the day's young.

Bye, Dave.

Good not talking to you.

Oh, boy.

Here are your pills, Bill.

- And these are for you. - Give it to me!

Barry, what are you doing?

- No! - Stop!

I'm okay, Jeff. Just go back to your room.

What are you doing to me?

Barry, stop it!

- What's happening? - Barry!

Stop! What are you doing to me?

Can I get some help here!

Barry, stop it. You're killing him.

Barry!

- I can't breathe. - Watch out, step back!

- I can't breathe! - What's happening?

Help him!

- Barry! - Everybody stay calm.

Check his pulse.

We're done treating you like Audrey.

- No more food, no more chat. - Good.

'Cause you made her fat and boring.

Oh, that's right...

And she's dead.

Then you're going to help us solve a trouble.

Uh, 'scuse me.

Nathan, can I just see you over here for a second, please?

Um, okay, so I'm sorry.

I thought we were gonna play it cool

and treat her like Audrey. Or did...

We are. We're taking her on a case.

Her... who "her"?

- Mara? - Yeah.

Mara knows that we're treating her like Audrey,

and she's fighting us.

So we need a way to treat her like Audrey

without Mara realizing what we're doing.

Getting her on a troubled case is a way to do that.

'Cause Audrey's at her best when she's helping the troubled.

So we put her in a position to do that again.

If Mara doesn't know what we're up to, maybe

Audrey can sneak up on her.

I'd normally cuff her, but we need a way to keep this safe.

I may have an idea.

Then all we need is a case.

Barry was such a pussycat...

Till he choked the life out of this patient.

I can't understand why he would do this.

- Anybody see anything? - Yeah, all of them.

You'd think a psych ward would do bigger business in Haven.

Yeah.

Well, we better get these guys to the morgue.

Gloria, are you okay?

Chief, are you okay?

- I need a minute. - Okay.